Aunt Jemima Cartoon Causing Controversy in Cleveland
By Rob Tornoe | December 3rd, 2009 | PERMALINKA cartoon depicting an Ohio state senator as Aunt Jemima that appeared in an African American newspaper has led to calls for one of the paper’s advisors, NAACP President George Forbes, to step down.
The cartoon, which appeared on the front page of the Cleveland Call & Post last week, shows State Senator Nina Turner as Aunt Jemima, criticizing her for supporting a reform issue that the paper believes failed to address underperforming schools and criminal justice issues.

Cartoon by Walt Carr depicting Ohio State Senator Nina Turner as Aunt Jemima.
“It was intended to offend some people. The damage done by this public official was done to black people,” Forbes told Channel 3’s Tom Beres.
Stanley Miller, executive director of the Cleveland NAACP civil rights organization, which opposed Issue 6, told the Cleveland Plain Dealer he wasn’t upset about the politics behind the cartoon, but rather the negative stereotype that dates back decades.
“It’s more about the image of an African-American woman in 2009,” said Miller.
“Our opinions on these pages are just that: OUR OPINIONS,” the Call & Post wrote in a editorial defending the cartoon. “And we will continue taking tough stances regardless of the fallout that those stances may engender.”
Cleveland Council Majority Leader Phyllis Cleveland commented on this issue, calling the cartoon racist, sexist and degrading.
“You don’t have a monopoly on what’s good for the community. We have to tolerate all opinions and work together,” she said.
According to Channel 3, a similar controversy happened 20 years ago when the Plain Dealer published an editorial cartoon depicting a black woman officeholder in an Aunt Jemima-like outfit.
“The leader who lead the charge against the Plain Dealer was none other than George Forbes,” said Mary Anne Sharkey, Channel 3’s Political Analyst
[h/t - The Daily Cartoonist]
Comments: 3. ADD A COMMENT. |
|
Comments
Comment from Donna Barstow
Time December 4, 2009 at 12:05 am
Beth, Tina T would have been good, except…not made the point at all.
Here’s the biggest surprise to me: I didn’t know there was such a thing as African-American papers.[/naive]
Comment from Mike Peterson
Time December 4, 2009 at 7:31 am
The black press has faded considerably since the days when it led the civil rights push, thanks to the fact that mainstream papers then began to cover the African-American community, which they had not previously. As for the cartoon, I suspect the problem is more political than racial. There was some criticism when Essence magazine depicted Clarence Thomas as a lawn jockey, but that cover illustration was backed up with coverage that explained their disapproval of his politics. In the case of a political cartoon, it has to stand alone and therefore is much more subject to second-guessing and to attacks by people who used the stereotypes as a wedge to defend an ally.



American Cartoonists
Aislin (Terry Mosher)
Brian Adcock
Omar Abdallat
Arcadio Esquivel
Ares
Pierre Ballouhey
Joep Bertrams
Hassan Bleibel
Angel Boligan
Peter Broelman
Peter Bromhead
Patrick Chappatte
Pavel Constantin
Sergei Elkin
Martin Sutovec
Tayo Fatunla
Fares
Farhad Foroutanian
Manny Francisco
Damien Glez
Oguz Gurel
Shekhar Gurera
Rainer Hachfeld
Julius Hansen
Riber Hansson
Jianping Fan
Yaakov Kirschen
Igor Kodenko
Christo Komarnitski
Michael Kountouris
Matador
Victor Ndula
Jeremy Nell
Petar Pismestrovic
Khalil Rahman
Simanca
Herbjorn Skogstad
Stephane Peray
Ramzy Taweel
Martyn Turner
Anna Von Rebeur

































Comment from Beth Cravens
Time December 3, 2009 at 2:19 pm
Sweet Jehoshaphat. It’s not just the drawing it’s the wording too. Her name is Nina Turner. Why not a Tina Turner ref? It’s a sucky idea but hell, it’s better than Aunt Jemima!